The Illusion of Authenticity How Brands are Watering Down Social Media (1)
Tuesday, April 29, 2025

The Illusion of Authenticity: How Brands are Watering Down Social Media

In today’s digital landscape, platforms like TikTok and Instagram are inundated with brands striving to project authenticity.

Low-effort content on social media may seem that way. However, achieving a realistic low-effort look often requires a fair amount of effort. Consider how much work goes into making a pair of new jeans look worn in.  

However, this surge often produces a deluge of low-effort content that undermines genuine engagement. The critical question arises: Can true authenticity be achieved by brands online?

The Rise of Low-Effort Content

The allure of low-effort content is understandable; it’s cost-effective and quick to produce. Brands aiming to resonate with younger audiences often adopt this approach to appear more relatable. Yet, when executed without genuine intent, it can come across as disingenuous, eroding consumer trust.

For a lot of consumers, there’s something about trying too hard to look casual and carefree that feels a little gross. 

Authenticity: A Double-Edged Sword

While low-effort content has merits, authenticity requires more than unpolished visuals. It’s about conveying genuine brand values and fostering real connections. Merely mimicking trends without aligning them with the brand’s core message can backfire, leading to scepticism among consumers.

The Comment Section Conundrum

A noticeable trend is the proliferation of brand accounts in comment threads, often overshadowing genuine customer interactions. This practice can dilute the sense of community and deter authentic conversations. Brands should prioritise facilitating spaces where customers feel heard rather than dominating the discourse themselves.

There’s something dystopian about scrolling through a comment section filled with brand accounts replying to each other. 

It’s also crucial to remember that your comment sections are your responsibility.

Striking the Right Balance

True authenticity demands a balance between polished branding and genuine interaction. Brands should focus on:

  • Consistency: Ensuring content aligns with the brand’s core values and mission.
  • Transparency: Being open about products, services, and company practices.
  • Engagement: Prioritising meaningful interactions over self-promotion.

Final Thoughts 

While pursuing authenticity is commendable, it requires more than low-effort content and brand-centric commentaries. Brands must introspect and commit to genuine practices that resonate with their audience, fostering trust and loyalty in the digital age.

Coffey & Tea is WA’s leading social media agency dedicated to the tourism and hospitality industry. We work with brands throughout Western Australia to help their voice be heard.

If you’re interested in learning more about how our social media services can help your brand, please get in touch today.